Sunday, January 13, 2013

A Dozen Aphorisms Or Something

Stupidity requires an act of will.

Error must be corrected; it doesn't have to be acknowledged. Dee Hock, creator of Visa and MasterCard

If the perfect is the enemy of the good, is the adequate enemy of the inadequate? Is the necessary the enemy of "whatever, man."

People think moral relativity or situational ethics is easy -- hedonistic indulgences of the Playboy Philosophy -- but you're more likely to do right that way, than if the economic policy of a bunch of Bronze Age shepherds is your crutch.

The war between the theist and the atheist is over whether we should know God as God, or use some other name.  Samuel Butler

I'm for using a different name.

Adam and Eve kicked God out of the Garden.  Gregory Bateson  (Gregory thought it was a bad idea. God, you should note, is not a rule book.)

Gregory Bateson not withstanding, men who don't use the familiar forms of their personal names are trying to pull a fast one.

I watched Religulous, Bill Maher's 2008 comedy documentary about religion. You'd probably call me an atheist, but I found the movie smug and unkind. Sure, the interviewees were dumb and smug, and probably unkind, but the movie and Maher pretended to a superior knowledge. And a higher standard.

Some scientist -- I forget who or what kind -- said that Richard Dawkins probably doesn't persuade anybody to atheism or even to tolerance, and the people who agree with him don't need to read him.  (About God, anyway. Dawkins is an interesting thinker about evolution.)

A guy I used to cross paths with had lived in Atlanta for a while. He was appalled that, when he enrolled his kids in little league, one of the key dads asked him for a hundred bucks. "Don't worry, you'll get it back." Later he asked them what the hundred dollar routine was about. "It's to keep the niggers out." He was appalled, but the interesting thing is that this guy and the other little league dads vote the same way.

We heard a news story about the gang-rape murder in India. The cops argued about jurisdiction before getting medical attention to the victims; as many men as women have demonstrated; the courts have gagged the press, ostensibly for the privacy of a dead woman whose family wants to get the word out; India is the home of suttee; we wondered about the demographic of thugs who pull evil stunts like this. Conclusion: India is split between cosmopolitan pragmatists struggling toward justice and a place in the ecology of their world, and authoritarian, superstitious barbarians. Just like America.  Is that the spirit of our world right now?

Friday, January 11, 2013

Buckminster Fuller Quotes

Fuller claimed that humanity is in its "final examination." The man died in 1983, well before the Soviet collapse, so his preoccupation was nuclear war. One of his books was titled Utopia or Oblivion. Oblivion of course being nuclear holocaust, because wars are fought over resources the combatants believe to be scare. (Fuller believed they are mistaken.)

Utopia amounted to opening a valve that would let human ingenuity solve the problem of scarcity. Fuller called us "four billion billionaires, as yet unaware of their good fortune."

Here are some Fuller quotes that fit. They come from the first chapter, "The Dawn of Einstein's Universe," of Cosmography: A Posthumous Scenario for the Future of Humanity.

"[Fuller's invention, the geodesic dome] is the only structure we know of that gets stronger as it gets larger and has no limit to its span."

"When we double the diameter of a geodesic dome, we increase the volume by a factor of 8 and the surface by a factor of 4." (This lowers the heating bill.)

"My intuition seemed to describe an evolution that is intent upon developing humans to the point where they can achieve total physical success."

(Writing about what we call military spin-off technology) "For example, electric refrigeration., first used in battleships, is adopted a generation later for use in the domestic environment on dry land."

"Of course, acting with conscious direction is the next stage of human evolution. I call this discipline anticipatory design science."

"[Politics could never] produce so much high-standard life support with so little material and energy investment as now, for the first time in history, to be able to sustain all humanity at ever higher standards of living than we have ever before experienced or dreamed of."

"[Acquiring useful technology by developing it to wage war] inadvertently also produces life-supporting technology, but it tkes a quarter of a century longer than it would if humanity first recognized the public longing to attain sustainable peace for all humanity and directly used the same high-technology production for livingry rather than for armaments."

I blogged a week or two ago about Fuller's assertion, in this same book, that the Mayans built their pyramids' foundations tangent to the Earth's spherical surface. I said I would track down Fuller's adjuvant for Cosmography, Kiyosh Kuromiya.

Unfortunately, we lost Kiyoshi-san to AIDS in 2000. He was born in an internment camp in Wyoming in 1943, and was a witty and energetic human rights activist. Apparently, his parents named him Steven and, as a kid, he went by the name Steve.

Kiyoshi Kuromiya was active in ACT UP, and founded the Critical Path Project, an organization that continues to supply AIDS sufferers with internet access.

I also exchanged e-mails about Mayan engineering with someone at the Buckminster Fuller Institute with no progress toward an answer.

I'd be obliged for any suggestions.

Thursday, January 10, 2013

A Different Take On The Idea Of Mind

More on Fuller tomorrow, particularly about how he saw us as problem solvers, but first another point of view on mind.

Fuller saw mind as uniquely human, and noticing patterns in sensory information processed by human brains. Gregory Bateson saw mind as immanent in all life, roses, redwood forests, the US Senate, you, me. Rather than dividing existence between mind and matter. Bateson divided it between life and non-life.

Here are his six criteria for mind:

1. Mind is an aggregate of interacting parts or components.

2. The interaction between parts of mind is triggered by difference.

3. Mental process requires collateral energy.

4. Mental process requires circular (or more complex) chains of determination.

5. In mental process, the effects of difference are to be regarded as transforms (i.e. coded versions) of events which precede them.

6. The description and classification of these processes of transformation disclose a hierarchy of logical types immanent in the phenomena.

It might be an interesting exercise to try to map Fuller's idea of mind onto Bateson's criteria. Right now, I'm dubious, but I haven't actually sat down and asked myself -- for instance -- "What are the interacting parts of Fuller's mind?"

Wednesday, January 9, 2013

Buckminster Fuller Tells How People Are Different From Other Animals

Buckminster Fuller thought that people's purpose was to be problem solvers. (He also thought that this was what will save our sorry collective ass.)

I've transcribed a thousand words or so of Fuller's thinking from Cosmography: A Posthumous Scenario for the Future of Humanity  about this idea. What he's saying is that other creatures got photosynthesis, fur, wings, etc. We got mind.

He distinguishes between brain and mind, saying that brains interpret the senses, while minds discover the patterns in what we sense.

In this excerpt Fuller discusses the scientific path to Newton's description of the relationship between distance and attraction that we call gravity, paying detailed attention to Kepler's discovery of the surprising way that the planets' obits relate to each other. He uses gravitation to stand for all of the natural laws which only humans seem capable of learning.


Over half a century ago, when I embarked on my "experiment in individual initiative," I set before myself(as I have repeatedlt ever since then) one very large question: What is our function here in Universe?

My first answer to that question came from two three closely related observations:

1. That all known living organisms other than humans have some integral bodily equipment that gives them special operating capabilities in special environments.

2. That many creatures, including humans, have brains, and that brains are always and only sorting the information reported by the senses and integrating this information into system images and therewith coordinating nervous control responses or forming improved new system imagings. Brains are therefore always dealing with special case experience -- for example, "This one smells a little sweeter than that one." Brains must sleep periodically. Brains deal in beginnings and endings of special-case considerations. Brains are physical, temporal, and frequently terminaled.

3. Humans also have a faculty unidentified with any other creatures -- the faculty of mind. Minds are always and only concerned with the discovery of eternal constant interrelationships manifest in a myriad of special-case experiences of the brain, which interrelationships are not to be found in any one of the special-case system components considered separately.

One of the most important events of classical science involving the interrelationship findings by the human mind is demonstrated by the mathematician-astronomer Johannes Kepler, whose story I shall recount here.

Based on his accurate observations and measurements, Kepler found that all the planets of which he was aware (a) were of different sizes, (b) operated at different distances from the Sun, (c) orbited the Sun at different rates, and (d) traveled their respective orbits  at different rates. Kepler said that the planets, though apparently on the same team, seemed to be utterly disordered. He then said they did share one thing: the fact of all going around the same Sun. As a mathematician, he knew he could assign these planets something else in common. He also knew that given two known constants, one may discover other interrelationships within the team. Kepler then assigned a common constant to each and all the known planets -- exactly the same increment of calendar time.

Starting at the same moment of calendar time and finishing at the same monet of calendar time, Kepler observed and recorded the plants' concurrent orbital travel over a twenty-one day period. this gave him the data for graphing the slices-of-pie-shaped, triangular patterns formed by each of the starting and finishing radii of measured distance from the Sun to each planet at the start and finish of the twenty-one-day event. The arc of travel distance between the start and finish closed the radii ends to form triangular shapes. Kepler intuitively decided to calculate the area of each of them. Doing so, he found that they were not only similar areas but were elegantly, exactly the same size.

He surmised that the planets could not sweep out exactly the same cosmic area unless they were coordinating in some exact manner. Since the planest were not touching one another, they could not be coordinating like toothed gears. Far from touching, these massive bodies were rotating and orbiting millions of miles distant from one another.

Kepler was forced to conclude that there was an invisible, unsmellable, soundless, untouchable, intertensionally restraining force governing the planets' orbital motions.

The work and findings of Kepler's contemporary Galileo regarding the exact mathematical rate of acceleration of "falling bodies" led to Isaac Newton's discovering the mathematical expression of the gravitational laws of Universe. Newton found that the interattraction of any two celestial bodies always varies inversely with the second power of the arithmetical distances intervening. Thus, halve the distance, and increase the interattractiveness fourfold.

Here again we have the human mind discovering what the brain's sensing is utterly incapable of apprehending. The mind can, and does, from time to time discover the only mathematically expressible laws governing these nonsensorially discoverable macro-microcosmic interrelationships which always hold true in all special-case instances. When such initial discoveries are found to be exceptionless, they become known as "laws" -- hence, the generalized laws of science.

Exceptionlessness can be termed eternal. Human mind has discovered a meager  inventory of these only mathematically statable, eternal laws governing the physical design and operation of Universe. These laws have never been found to contradict one another. All have been found to be interaccomodative. All of them may be objectively employed in special-case technology.

Humans possessed of the family of generalized mathematical laws governing all the relevant, variable factors in aerodynamics are able to build a flying machine by which they can outfly the birds in speed and altitude. Humans can lend one another their "wings."

That humans alone of all known phenomena have access to the great design laws of Universe immediately implies that we must have been introduced into Universe for some very significant ultimate functioning.

Tuesday, January 8, 2013

Green Lightning At The Blue Moon: Talking Disaster Blues

My transition group met last night at the Blue Moon coffee house on Lake Street. (It's something else with the same name, Kate.)

Transition is a movement to replace oil with community. The idea is that climate change and peak oil are a one-two punch that will cripple industrial economy. The powers that be either can't or won't stop sawing away at the branch upon which we perch so precariously, so it's up to us. ("Grass roots" mixed the metaphor too hilariously to use or lose, so I had to put it in parenthesis.)

We're reading Sharon Astyk's Making Home. We covered chapters 4 & 5 last night, but Schroedinger's cat still has my copy, so I listened and doodled surreptitious caricatures of the seven people at the table. Michelle, who is local, but just moved back to the Twin Cities after eight years in Sarasota, FL, chaired the conversation, and very nicely kept it, more or less, on topic.

In a prior meeting, we had established that it is important enough to keep your home that you sacrifice some pretty important stuff to do so. Home is a base of operations, site for workshop and garden, and toehold in your community. In hard times, let go of your phone, gas, and electrical services, if this will help you make your rent or mortgage payments. Good trick in Minnesota, I guess but freezing in the dark is better than being homeless. The part that sticks in my mind was that we could sort of run drills. Lee and her family have shut off their utilities for a day, much to their teenagers' dismay. When their drier crashed, they didn't replace it.

We also talked about a backhoe accident downtown that flooded a parking garage, diverted traffic, shut down businesses, and cancelled Guthrie Theater performances.

Even for economies, "In the midst of life, etc."

We are enjoying mild weather up here on the 45th parallel, this second week of January. We could see temps in the forties, and it's already been above freezing. There's a chance of rain on Thursday, with a return to normal temperatures behind that. Somebody from Kansas City last night mentioned that down there, what happens is the rain freezes on the branches, which snap off and fall onto the power lines.

"There was all this green lightning, and nobody could figure out what it was. It turned out that the transformers were exploding."

If this stuff is all true, I'm not the grasshopper anymore. I'm a freaking ant!

Monday, January 7, 2013

Adolph Eichmann, Moishe Dayan, And the Limits To Growth

Israel hanged Adolph Eichmann in 1962, thirteen months after they caught him Argentina. Co-incidentally, the Oscar-winning film Judgement at Nuremberg hit movie theaters in 1961. I was in the Seventh Grade when Eichman died, and I was appalled that anybody would hang anybody.

Eichmann's crime was to be the logistical genius who designed and ran the system that transported Eastern European Jews to their deaths. His defense was that he was a cog in the machine, only doing what his superiors ordered. In fact, Eichmann may have been an enthusiastic executioner, an anti-semite, and an ambitious opportunist. The joke among the junior high set at the time of Eichman's death was "Can't you Jews take a joke?"

In Judgement, the sympathetic Judge, played by Spencer Tracy, is kind and attentive to the Germans he meets, witnesses, the accused, a young woman at a sausage vendor's, the servants at the mansion where he's lodged, the widow (Marlene Dietrich) of a general hanged for war crimes. They are all "little people," small cogs in a great machine.

Much is made, by defense counsel, Maximillian Schell, of the fact that the defendants, particularly one learned and revered jurist, were caught up in the system, and that convicting them convicted the entire German population. The story takes place during the Soviet Berlin blockade, and the judge experiences considerable pressure to slap the defendants wrists, and let them go on their ways. The Allies need the Germans on their side to meet the Soviet threat. The judge does the right thing, if not theexpeditious one.

I was kind of an oblivious kid.

 For instance, I have no recollection of the Cuban Missile Crisis. That happened in the fall of my Eighth Grade year, when you'd think I was old enough to notice.

But somehow I took Eichmann's hand-washing defense, that he was following orders, as the epitome of evil. I remember a cartoon of Moishe Dayan -- maybe by Edward Sorel -- at the time of the Six Day War, in which Dayan says, "I was only following marauders."

I couldn't help but oppose the Vietnam War, and the contradictions and compromises of work, particularly post-Limits to Growth -- were a handicap to the career of one of the best minds of my generation, namely me.

I've mellowed in early senescence.

Howard T. Odum pointed out that a system is limited by what its sub-systems support and what the larger system in which it's embedded will allow.

What's a little feller to do as the world crashes around him?

Sunday, January 6, 2013

Why Rich? Why Poor?

Sam and Marissa returned an old CoEvolution Quarterly I had loaned them. We were talking about space exploration a few months ago, and there is a story in the magazine, Manuel's Tears, that made the point that a space colony would live at the expense of people on the planet.

There's also a quote from John Ruskin on the back cover.

In the community regulated only by laws of supply and demand, but protected from open violence, the persons who become RICH are, generally speaking, industrious, proud, resolute, covetous, prompt, methodical, sensible, unimaginative, insensitive, and ignorant. The persons who remain POOR are the entirely foolish, the entirely wise, the idle, the reckless, the thoughtful, the dull, the imaginative, the sensitive, the well-informed, the improvident, the irregularly and impulsively wicked, the clumsy knave, the open thief, and the entirely merciful, just, and godly person.

Saturday, January 5, 2013

Cloud Atlas

Saw Cloud Atlas this evening, second run and the Deco-Moderne Riverview Theater  where we see most of our movies, with Sam and Marissa.

The film is an adaptation of a novel of the same name by David Mitchell, directed by and with a script by Tom Tykwer and the Wachowskis. It takes place in several eras, with Hanks, and actors including Halle Barrry, Hugo Weaving, playing multiple roles during periods from slave-trading to post-futuristic tribal. I thought one of the villains was doing a Hugh Grant impression, then learned from the credits that it was Hugh Grant. Cloud Atlas is the name of a piece of music written by one of the characters, during the 78 RPM era.

The reviews we read weren't good, but Cloud Atlas was nice. It's been a long time since I've seen a puzzle movie, and this one spoke well of the human soul. Joe Versus the Volcano and That Thing You Do notwithstanding, it's a long way from Bosom Buddies.

Friday, January 4, 2013

Travis McGee Depressive Existential Hero


The legend is that John D. MacDonald began writing fiction as a WWII GI so he could send something meaningful to his wife by censored mail. She submitted his detective stories to magazines, and began his career.

MacDonald was a "writing machine" who cranked out over fifty books, and innumerable short stories. His prose is a little florid, but it's readable with few mechanical problems.

Example: "Hefty Salvation Army Lassies in their wagon-train bonnets dingle-dangled spare change into their kettles, and fat foam Santas were affixed to the palm boles and light standards, high enough to keep the kids from yanking their foam feet off." That was from Pale Gray for Guilt, of the Travis McGee series, told in first person by Travis McGee, who is prone to describing skies as full of "smutch" and machines as going "pockety-wock." The cutesiness is usually ironic.

As an informant MacDonald was only middling reliable. It's pretty obvious he knew about LSD from the inside, but he confused Monet and Manet, and I haven't been able to find online evidence of a real Dormed sleep machine -- an electronic gadget that keeps the girl in  Girl in the Plain Brown Wrapper -- in half an hour of searching.

MacDonald's series character Travis McGee regarded women as real humans. Interetingly, at a time when Playboy was serializing James Bond, McGee had little use for Playboy, key clubs, or Hugh Hefner. Still, sex was "full-frontal."

"But her breathing changed and she pushed her hips so close she could not fail to notice what all the thought of ice and pain had failed to quell.

"She sat up abruptly and unbuttoned her blouse and took it off. She kept her eyes shut as though unwilling to watch what she was doing. She made a mouth, as the French say, a mouth of resignation and self contempt. She knelt, put her thumbs inside the waist elastic of the baggy white slacks and peeled them down, rolled back an kicked them off. She had worn nothing under either the blouse or the slacks. Her body was elegant, sleek as fire-warm silk and ivory, with a deceptive flavor of immaturity about it, the nipples small and pink, the pubic hair a sofft sooty smudge."

McGee longs for love, but rejects a life of punch cards, pension plans, and decimal-fraction-sized families, preferring his chosen occupation of "Ke-Ho-Tay" in tin-can armor, with broken lance and spavined steed. This is a problem for a series character, and -- somebody told me -- McGee's conquests in twenty-one books was in the fifties. Lois was murdered, Pidge jilted our hero, Dana went back into her shell, Puss disappeared (we find out in another novel that she died), Annie preferred her career, and so on.


Liberal MacDonald's homophobia seems quaint, slanderous and exploitive forty years after Stonewall. Desk clerk's stifle yawns behind dainty fists, and "the butch" live in "colonies" where they guard their "brides" from "true males," dispensing beatings "stevedores would be proud of."

Travis McGee is a Florida boat bum, who lives aboard a fifty foot sybaritic houseboat he won playing poker. The loser's friends led him away before he could write an IOU with his Brazilian mistress as collateral.

McGee makes his living retrieving things stolen legally, and taking half the value as fee. He does not expect to live to great age -- when he would be less capable of enjoying himself anyway -- so takes his retirement in installments.

MacDonald created McGee as a kind of depressed hero, tall, strong, handsome -- if scarred and shopworn -- a former paratrooper and professional running back, who lives life on his own terms, but describes himself as living outside the light and warmth cast by the fire, unable to take part in our songs and laughter. It's a kind of fantasy fulfillment and moral caution to his readers, mostly WWII and Korea vets or their contemporaries, educated, a pipe smokers, Democrats, libertarians, cynics, thinking of themselves a s men's men, but supporting lives of dinner at the club with wife and kids.

The typical Travis McGee novel begins with McGee taking his ease after making a big score. An old friend, girlfriend, or somebody he owes big makes a claim on his attention. The loss is seldom something that fits with his fee structure, and it's been taken by a sociopath, someone who has no empathy for other people, who imagines we are all as empty as himself.

McGee starts looking into the case, randomly stirring things up. (In several of the books, McGee needs information from a tertiary character who is not forthcoming. McGee tortures the informant, feeling soiled afterwards. Fortunately MacDonald abandoned this device after the early novels.) He meets the villain, sort of an evil Travis McGee, alerting the villain to his presence. As McGee is set to steal the prize back, the villain attacks him, injuring him seriously before McGee can dispatch him.

Every hero needs a sidekick, and McGees is a gentle, charismatic, semi-retired economist, named Meyer. McGee is not in every book. In spite of being highly moral, Meyer discovers a taste and talent for being a con man. Because of his economics contacts and curriculum vitae, Meyer can often take the con to very high levels.

The thing that distinguishes the Travis McGee novels from other mystery thrillers, is McGee's soliloquizing about Florida, the environment, human dignity, and -- quoting Meyer -- economics.

In 1973's The Scarlet Ruse, Meyer is telling McGee how he met the defrauded stamp dealer Hirsch Fedderman. Fedderman had helped Meyer develop an economic indicator based on the activity in markets for rare commodities like stamps.

"I wanted the kind of warning they used to have in France. When the peasants started buying gold and hiding it, you knew the storms were coming."

"Are they coming, O Great Seer?"

"What do you think we are standing out in the middle of with neither spoon nor paddle?"

Later in the same book:

"...so divide everything into two hundred million equal parts. Everything in theis country that is fabricated. Steel mills, speedboats, cross-country power lines, scalpels, watchbands, fish rods, ski poles, plywood, storage batteries, everything. Break it down into raw materials, then compute the power requirements and the fossil fuels needed to make everybody's share in this country. Know what happens when you apply that formula to all the peoples of all the other nations of the world?

"You come up against a bleak fact, Travis. there is not enough material on and in the planet to ever give them what we're used to. The emerging nations are not going to emerge -- not into our pattern at least. Not ever. We've bagged it all. Technology won't come up with a way to crowd the Yangtze River with Munequitas." (The Munequita -- "Little Doll" -- is McGee's twin engine speedboat, behind which he is towing his latest romantic interest, and the sociopathic villain of the book.)

Wednesday, January 2, 2013

The Fiscal Cliff At The End Of Growth


Apropos of the "fiscal cliff" legislation, MPR quoted a China Daily editorial yesterday as saying that the US couldn't continue our debt-fueled prosperity, and that the legislature couldn't continue to "kick the can down the road."

Maybe they can't help but "kick the can down the road."

The middle class, which Democratic politicians claim to want to protect, has the largest economic -- not to say ecological --  footprint. (The poor are too poor, the rich are too few.)

It all comes down to our ecological footprint. Our economy would have been fine, if we hadn't come up against the planet's limits to growth.

So dealing with the problem of keeping society going come down to operating ecologically, and operating ecologically will change the way that comfortable working-class folks live.

Not kicking the can down the road would amount to figuring out how to reduce our ecological footprint without handing your House or Senate seat over to a demagogue.

And without precipitating an economic disaster.

CBC news program As It Happens, interviewed End of Growth author Jeff Rubin. The interviewer treated Rubin's comments as novel. Maybe Rubin's ideas weren't novel to the interviewer -- they haven't been news to me since 1972 -- but might as well have been in Martian for most of the audience.

Pity, because that's what we need to talk about, if it's possible to avoid economic collapse..

Tuesday, January 1, 2013

Ronald Reagan, Speed Freak

My profile of Bill McKibben (with solutions for climate change) will be in Duluths's Zenith City (semi-) Weekly around the beginning of February.

Don't live in Duluth? You can find archived past profiles -- including Buckminster Fuller, Dorothy Day, and hero of the confederacy John C. Calhoun --  at

http://zenithcitynews.com/directory.htm.

Look for
Faces of Wisdom in the archived issues.

It's the year after the end of the Mayan Calendar.

Twelve years after 2001, and we still haven't sent a talking computer to Jupiter..

Thirteen years after Y2K.

We were going to "party like it's 1999."

Buckminster Fuller thought we'd have solved our problems or blown the planet to smithereens by 1985.

It all seems so quaint.

E. F. Schumacher published Small Is Beautiful forty years ago.

The Limits to Growth came out in 1972.

If four decades have passed, and Americans still haven't starved or choked on our own waste, those guys must have been wrong. Right?

President James Earl Carter was curious and worried about those two books. He entertained Schumacher at the White House, and installed solar panels on its roof.

Then we decided that it was "morning in America," took down the panels and suppressed Carter-commissioned plans for getting off the petroleum tit.

Here's Bill McKibben's on how we  got away with ignoring the environmental Jeremiahs from  Eaarth: Making a Life on a Tough New Planet:

"The problem was not that Reagan's sunny disposition masked a fascist soul; the problem was Reagan's sunny disposition."

How did the Reagan administration get away with ignoring growth's limits?

"...there was still enough slack in the system that it wouldn't come crashing in on them. Deregulation -- the relentless notion that government was the problem and that freed from its strictures the economy would grow -- was in the short term remarkably effective. We would flog the economy back to life, give it a dose of economic amphetamine that would last for fifteen years, the years when our slide (would) gain irresistible momentum."

Saturday, December 29, 2012

David Foster Wallace Wannabee Submits A Story

I used to post longer pieces. This link's to a post from a couple years back about Stewart Brand's answer to climate change, Whole Earth Discipline.

For the last few months, I've concentrated on writing profiles of systems thinkers -- Faces of Wisdom --  for Duluth's Zenith City (semi) Weekly. Here's my profile of gardener and soil builder John Jeavons

I finished my newest profile, on 350.org founder Bill McKibben, today. I tried to write it yesterday, but wound up at 1200 words. I'm usually published at 800 words, but my editor, Jen, likes me to write long. She says, "I can cut, but I can't add." Still a third is a lot to cut gracefully, so I wrote a second version, 900 words long.

(Ironically, I proposed a series like the old Ripley's Believe It or Not, with fewer than a hundred words.)

David Foster Wallace's Consider the Lobster (start with the fourth one down) is a collection of published essays, as submitted. It's interesting to see what wound up on the floor.

Maybe someday.

Friday, December 28, 2012

People As Subsystems

Ecologist Howard Odum noted in Environment Power and Society that what a system can do is limited by its subsystems, and by the larger system of which it is a part.

If we think of a person as a system, his or her subsystems would include metabolism, wealth, personal connections, knowledge base, intellectual firepower, etc. He or she would be a subsystem of a society, whose operations oblige and proscribe various activities and accomplishments. A Yanamamo won't build a helicopter, and a North Korean won't direct a 3D, CGI film of The Catcher in the Rye.

And, we have to wonder, how can an American find a way to live a just, satisfying, and ecologically-based life?

Buckminster Fuller: Dark Horse In The Race To Save The Planet

A wild card in the struggle to save civilization is one key idea of Buckminster Fuller's. Bucky said lots, but this probably is his most solid, and maybe useful, idea.

He said it's invisible, because it involves a kind of knowledge most of us don't have or pay understand.

Modern alloys have many times the tensile strength of rocks, lumber, or concrete -- conventional building materials -- and greater tensile strength than nineteenth century steel. Of course, conventional buildings are made by piling things on top of other things -- compressively -- and materials' compressive strengths are relatively pitiful.

Also, Fuller's geometry, which you can see in his invention, the geodesic dome, is tensile -- it hangs together. Build our structures using Fuller's tensile geometry and incredibly strong modern materials, and it only takes a tiny fraction of the material conventional techniques would. Those domes are hanging from themselves, and could cover counties without any pillars.

The combination of modern materials and a kind of building which hangs instead of stacks might be economical enough to make us the planet of billionaires Fuller claimed we are, "entirely unaware of our good fortune."

In the twenties, Fuller analyzed a model modern house, proposed by the American Institute of Architects, realizing that all of the lumber, plumbing, concrete, wires, appliances, etc. would weigh 150 tons. He designed his Dymaxion House to provide the same area and functions for three tons. The Dymaxion House would have been mass-produced, so there would have been time savings, as well.

After World War II, he built two prototype Dymaxion Houses, which operated as proposed, and weighed...three tons each.

Objections are that these structures would be unconventional and startling, compete with existing industries, aren't the kind of things individuals can do by themselves (industrial production versus craft), requiring cooperation, and the possibility that there would be hidden infrastructure belying apparent economies. But these are just questions. It would be nice if people caught on to possibilities like Buckminster Fuller's in sufficient number to start having a conversation.

The stakes are too high not to.

Thursday, December 27, 2012

The Nation On Secession

I let my Harper's subscription lapse, and stopped listening to Democracy Now for the sake of my mental health, but I sneaked a look at the current Nation today at the library.

Calvin Trillin about post-election secessionists: We do respect your point of view/We're glad to see the back of you.

There's a more prosaic thousand words about secessionists, later in the magazine, pointing out that their states, ironically, are major beneficiaries of big federal government, and comparing the American movement with regional/ethnic movements in Europe -- Scottish, Catalan, etc.

Off the cuff: I'm torn. We're all in this collapsing world economy together, and giving Yahoos the right to self determination could sabotage reasonable people's chances. On the other hand, they seem to be doing a decent job of shooting our collective feet already.

Continuing the motif, there's also a review of John G. Turner's Brigham Young: Pioneer Prophet, about the founder of the little theocracy in the basin.

Wednesday, December 26, 2012

Logicomix

Most humans behave irrationally. All the more reason to pursue the study of logic... Of course I am also human  and thus am no stranger to fits of non-logical thinking. But I can also discern these tendencies in myself and thus am more able to resist them...

                                          Bertrand Russell, quoted in Logicomix, Doxiadis, Papadimitriou, Pasppadatos, and Di Donna, 2009, Bloomsbury, NY

The Complete Cartoons of the New Yorker.

Barbara and I spent Christmas Day at Sam and Marissa's house. Sam is our 31-year old. I looked through his copy of The Complete Cartoons of the New Yorker.

A lot of the drawings from the twenties and thirties made me laugh, and the drawings from the twenties were great -- draughtsmanship and composition equal to high art and illustration, some of the design derived from Cubism.

Beginning in the forties, I laughed a lot less. My reaction was usually, "Oh yeah, I get it." The drawing was okay -- cartoon-level

Then sometime in the nineties, the cartoons started to get funny again. Were they really, or was it that their themes were closer to mine, and the kind of gags were ones I'm conditioned to laugh at?

And if that's true, what does it say about the cartoonists eighty and ninety years ago?

Oh, and William Hamilton's drawings are twenties quality.

Monday, December 24, 2012

Wayne LaPierre Crazy?

Wayne LaPierre met the press Sunday and said, "If putting armed police in schools is crazy, call me crazy."

Okay.

Oh, yeah, and would Colt Firearms be willing to pony up the guns? Maybe PointBlank Body Armor would come across with the Kevlar vests.


Anxiety And Alprazamalama

                EXT. HOSPITAL EMERGENCY ROOM - DAY

BOB pauses, exiting the emergency room. He wears a drab business suit, mops his forehead and looks up with visible relief.

               BOB

I thought I was having a heart attack. Thank God it was only crippling anxiety disorder.

               INT. DOCTOR'S OFFICE - DAY

               DOCTOR

Fortunately for anxiety sufferers like Bob, now there's Alprazamalama.

             STILL LIFE OF ALPRAZAMALAMA

              HURRIED VOICE-OVER

Check with your doctor to see if Alprazamalama is right for you. Check with your doctor if you experience any of the following while taking Alprazamalama: depression, thoughts of suicide, suicide, thoughts of mass murder, mass murder, chest pains, racing heart, dizziness, nausea, uncontrolled muscle movements, jaundice, hallucinations, or anxiety.

Saturday, December 22, 2012

NRA:Short Deck Or Stacking It?

So...

NRA Executive Veep, Wayne LaPierre ("Help, I'm a rock."), says we should put an armed guard in every American school, and do it by the time the kids get back from Christmas. I figured those guys would be among the fiscally responsible. How many schools are there in the country? There are some cops in some schools, but LaPierre is calling for a major jobs program.

Is the NRA playing with a full deck?

Thursday, December 20, 2012

Those Days Are Gone Forever

My mother's maternal grandfather worshipped Lincoln, edited a small-town, Republican newspaper, supported the community of Macomb, Illinois, and provided for a very comfortable childhood for me and my sibs. He was a die-hard nineteenth century libertarian. Once he gave Mom five Depression-era bucks for thinking for herself and writing what amounted to a socialist school theme, a theme which appalled and embarrased my Democratic Granddad.

I call myself a conservative, but nobody else does. "Pal" (my great grandfather) probably wouldn't either, but I like to think that I could persuade him. In a morally relativistic universe, I try to stay in sync with the largest morally meaningful system. Pretty good trick, huh?

Like Wes Jackson says, we all live in the extractive economy.

But, like Barbara says, degree matters. What passes for conservatism these days is a bunch of what Stephen Gaskin calls "plungers" and "bet-the-farm-on-a hunch-boys." (And their dupes).

That was okay for Pal, who lived on the upslope of peak oil. During the Great Depression, he backed his hunches, and new oil reserves backed them too. It even seemed, especially with the Green Revolution, a dozen or twenty years later, that his plunging helped improve the commonweal.

Those days are gone forever.

Wednesday, December 19, 2012

To Heck With The Dialectic

Post-presidential election, a guy I know, a skilled craftsman, asked me if it had turned out the way I wanted. It had on one level, but, on another, there was no way it could have turned out the way it needed to. I tried to explain, but my friend said very nicely that he wasn't interested.

His own politics are Independent, or at least adamantly moderate. Sad, because we're in a bind, and the extremists know it, and further, we, on all sides, are serious about surviving and thriving. You can compromise about things where people have different interests; everybody gives a little. You can't compromise on whether or not civilization persists.

Sort Of A Sacrament

And then there is that other relationship which is emphatically not "sort of." Many men have gone to the stakefor the proposition that the bread and wine are not "sort of" the body and blood.

Gregory Bateson, "Metalogue: Why a Swan?" Steps to an Ecology of Mind

We're All A Little Crazy

We all make errors [in recognizing metphor, humor, fantasy, etc.] at various times. I'm not sure that I've ever met anybody that doesn't suffer from "Schizophrenia P" more or less.

Greogory Bateson in "Epidemiology of Schizophrenia," Steps to an Ecology of Mind

The Problem With Ronnie

The problem was not that Reagan's sunny disposition somehow masked a fascist soul; the problem was his sunny disposition.

Bill McKibben in Eaarth: Making a Life on a Tough New Planet

Quote For the Moment

Error must be corrected. It doesn't have to be acknowledged.

Dee Hock, creator of Visa

Tolerate The Second Amendment


My own gun ownership -- a .22 caliber target pistol in the late 1970s -- was symptomatic of a then-loose screw.

The Second Amendment is unique in the right's apparently being contingent on the necessity of a "well regulated militia," and in being so object-specific. Swords and flintlock rifles. The arms we may bear preceded even Eli Whitney's mass production.

The argument I've heard most frequently for preserving private arsenals has more to do with fear of government than supporting it as part of a militia. In fact, in an interview with Talk of the nation's Neal Conan, More Guns Less Crime author John Lott said that Columbine High School shooter Dylan Klebold had written to his state representative objecting to proposed anti-gun legislation, and that the law went into effect on the day of the shootings.

I'm sure Conan had to restrain himself from asking if that were a threat.

Be all that as it may, the current clamor for gun control seems mistaken:

Everybody has guns. When I was a Minneapolis energy auditor, poking around in people's houses to save heat. I saw many guns.

Among friends, I know three machine guns, and they aren't going anywhere. Their owners, Vietnam-era vets, will hide them and vote Tea Party. That's unfortunate because one of them, at least, is a sensible and humane guy, and you don't have to dig very far to see it.

We're looking at some nasty weather. I believe that dealing with the limits to growth will require some restrictions on personal liberty, and I don't want to alienate anybody who can help. Let them keep their well oiled security blankets.

More immediately, we might be able to keep guns out of the hands of the nation's Adam Lanzas, but I'm betting that mass shootings will continue at a rate of about twenty a year. Whatever goads somebody to put innocent strangers to death -- children for pete'ssake --  will remain, and gun-control nuts will be disappointed. It ain't gonna be easy, but if we want to stop violent grandstanding, we'll need to go deeper.



Tuesday, December 18, 2012

Harold Kushner: Good Insight Comes From The Basilica

I listened to Harold Kushner's October talk at St. Mary's Basilica. I heard it on the radio, but I know that, for non-liturgical events, they put signs on the confessionals directing people to the bathrooms downstairs.

Kushner spoke about his recent book The Book of Job: When Bad Things Happen to a Good Person. Job, the original, is one of five books of the Bible that I've read all the way through. I've read it twice, once twenty years ago because Gregory Bateson quoted it, and again more recently and with greater understanding. (Matthew, Mark, Luke, and Revelations are the others; I tried Genesis but it wore me out.)

Kushner said he believes that the story -- God sorely afflicts a devout, virtuous, and prosperous man, who remains steadfast, and is rewarded with new prosperity -- was a folk tale. About 2500 years ago, some brilliant theologian and poet became dissatisfied with the story and used it to bracket a more nuanced examination of doubt, faith, and what it means to love God.

The message, according to Kushner, is that a world without suffering would be a world without growth, and if we can't get mad at God, it's a lifeless kind of love. God's message to us is that we will suffer, but He will not abandon us.

I'm more of a not-peace-but-the-sword kind of guy, but I enjoyed hearing Kushner.

During the question period, somebody asked about virtuous atheists and agnostics. Kushner said that God wants us to behave well, but isn't interested in the credit. He said that the people the questioner asked about are probably not really atheists and agnostics. The thing that keeps us doing good and avoiding evil is a notion of God.

That reminded me of a quote from Samuel Butler, a mostly forgotten nineteenth century British author, and critic of Darwin:

The argument between the theist and atheist is over whether we shall know God as God, or by some other name.

Monday, December 17, 2012

St. Paul Chamber Orchestra And The Social Contract

The St. Paul Chamber Orchestra is on strike . Money is the issue, and I'm sympathetic. these are skilled artists, with neurosystems and senses of beauty (probably a false distinction, but just "neurosystems" seems too cold) developed far beyond those of the people for whose pleasure, and especially, at whose pleasure, they perform. Maybe the occasional surgeon in the audience operates at that level, but mostly, it's just us duffers.

As the economy contracts, this is how it happens: faced with fewer resources, the MBAs who control the budget will reduce expenses where it's easiest. They know they can't get very far, asking for give backs from suppliers, bankers, and taxmen, and audiences and grantors are contributing at their limits, so they relieve the pressure on themselves by demanding help where it's easiest: subordinate (!) members of the team.

Quick review: There are twice as many mouths to feed as there were forty years ago, and there were a lot then. Also forty years ago, it took one unit of oil to drill eighty, now it takes twenty; we're pumping a lot of what's, near as I can figure, the real basis for our currency, but we burn a fourth of it for the privilege. Global warming and other forms of pollution (and pollution control) take a bite out of our wealth. Borrowing made sense as the economy expanded, because we could expect to service debt with wealth we planned to create with borrowed capital; now, as the economy contracts, payments to creditors will come from society's operating budget. And there has been a major concentration of wealth in the same forty-year period, so capital that might have gone to innovation and compensation, feathers the already plush nests of the SPCO's directors and major supporters.

I don't believe that workers, even workers as noble and virtuous as classical musicians, can justly expect compensation commensurate with "world-class music." But neither can performers in New York.

And neither can MBAs, and the venal lightweights who get rooms at the Crowne Plaza because it's too far to drive back to fucking Wayzata after the concert.

What the musicians, and other workers going forward, need to realize is that we're on the brink of the precipice, and we're in a struggle for standing room as it crumbles. Some old fart in a thousand-dollar suit, hundred-dollar haircut,  and a one-of-a-kind pair of gold cuff links is gonna try to knock you into the abyss, but the ground really is crumbling.

Forget ticket prices. Negotiate the social contract.